| Platinum | Sisters Meat and Smokehouse |
| Gold | Newport Avenue Market |
| Silver | Cinder Butte Meat |
| Bronze | Redmond Smokehouse |
| Top Pick | Central Oregon Butcher Boys |
| Top Pick | Fisher's Red Rock Meat Co |
| Top Pick | Primal Cuts Meat Market |
| Top Pick | The Meat Locker |
| Top Pick | We'Re The Wurst |