| Platinum | Kook'I |
| Gold | Bontà Natural Artisan Gelato |
| Silver | Cuppa Yo |
| Bronze | Goody's Soda Fountain & Candy |
| Top Pick | Goodys Chocolate & Ice Cream Factory |
| Top Pick | Grey Duck Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Ida's Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Little Slice of Heaven Cheesecakes |
| Top Pick | The Dough Nut |
| Top Pick | Too Sweet Cakes |