| Platinum | Mimi's Bagels |
| Gold | Big O Bagels |
| Silver | Bo's Falafel Bar |
| Bronze | 5th Street Bagels |
| Top Pick | Big Ed's Artisan Bread |
| Top Pick | Haven Bagels |
| Top Pick | Nancy P's Cafe & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Rockin' Dave's Bagel Bistro & Catering Co |
| Top Pick | The Sparrow Bakery |
| Top Pick | Too Sweet Cakes |