| Platinum | Pastini |
| Gold | Pisano's Woodfired Pizza |
| Silver | Bosa Food & Drink |
| Bronze | Cibelli's New York Pizza |
| Top Pick | 900 Wall |
| Top Pick | Little Pizza Paradise |
| Top Pick | Nome |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Salute Bend |
| Top Pick | The Point Pub & Grill |